Number Talks have become commonplace in many elementary math classrooms across North America to help students build their number sense and overall number fluency. This is amazing news! However, the reality is that while using **number talks** in the classroom can be helpful, I have witnessed on a number of occasions where students learn **how** to apply strategies without fully understanding **why** they work.

With the recent release of the new Ontario Ministry of Education Focusing on the Fundamentals of Math: A Teacher’s Guide document, I thought I’d pick something that is highlighted from the document and dive into it deeply from an approach outlined in the guide such as the Alex Lawson quote included in the document:

Children should learn their number facts. However, they would benefit from learning these facts by using an increasingly sophisticated series of strategies rather than by jumping directly to memorization.

For Ontario teachers, it is worth noting that the “new” document is simply highlighting parts of the current Ontario Grade 1 to 8 Mathematics Curriculum and is not new content. It is also worth noting that in this document that was advertised to go “back to basics,” is really just highlighting parts of the curriculum that the Ministry considers “fundamentals”. However, please know that this document does **not **promote rote memorization without understanding. When you search for the word “basic,” you find it in the actual text only twice, while the word “understand” comes up 46 times. So while this document was pitched as a “back to basics” document stuffed full of demands for rote memorization without worrying about conceptual understanding, that isn’t true at all. It is very well balanced and I’m very proud to share it with teachers in my district and across the province of Ontario.

To support the work of this document, I’m attempting to build in a Jo Boaler-style visual number talk series of **visual prompts** for multiplication to unpack, through investigation, the **halving and doubling strategy**. This is a great way to lower the floor on this task and ensure that all students in your classroom have an entry point.

Keep an eye out for **number properties** as we will be unpacking those near the end. The silent solution video is much longer than usual because I attempt to fully unpack how the halving and doubling strategy works using number properties.

Let’s dive in!

## Visual Prompt #1: Open Questioning to Lower the Floor

In the video above, we start with the following visual:

The prompt I would give students here is something like this:

Describe how many squares you see in as many ways as possible to your neighbour.

The intention here is for students to get beyond saying “32,” and to start saying things like:

- 4 groups of 8
- 8 groups of 4
- 4 plus 4 plus 4 plus 4 plus 4 plus 4 plus 4 plus 4
- 2 groups of 16
- …and so on

Then, I’d explicitly share this image:

By using the above image, I’d then prompt students with:

What might you say to describe how we have grouped the squares now?

Note that we are still leaving the questioning quite open, however I’m anticipating that students might say something like:

- 4 groups of 8; or,
- 8 items copied 4 times.

If I’m leading this **visual number talk **in a classroom, I’d be recording what students are saying on the chalkboard / whiteboard to model their description visually and symbolically.

Here’s what we might display for students who say “4 groups of 8” to ensure that all other students can “see” what the student sharing sees:

Then, I might display the same 32 squares, but **re-group visually** to show the following:

I’d then prompt students again to describe what they see and attempt to pay attention to the groupings outlined. Describe in words what it looks like and then, what could we write symbolically to represent the same groupings?

I am anticipating that students might come up with 2 groups of 2 groups of 8 or 2 groups of 8, copied 2 times, or similar.

The following visual shows what we might write to represent the verbal description of **2 groups of 2 groups of 8**:

Although, another student might think of it more like this working from the inside out:

I would then **re-group ****visually** another time and ask students to share with a neighbour how they might describe the following:

Here, I’m anticipating hearing students say something like **2 groups of 8 groups of 2 items**.

Again, we must keep in mind that other students might see it differently and we don’t want to discount how they are viewing things.

Re-grouping again to remove the groupings of 2 will result in the following:

Here, I’m anticipating students saying something like **2 groups of 16**.

Then, I might **re-group** by simply placing each **group of 16** into another group like shown below. What might students say now?

I’m anticipating that less students will see this right away, however what we have done is explicitly shared an example of the **identity property**:

We basically have **2 groups of 1 group of 16**. The **identity property **shows up when I place a single group inside another group. The result is the same, but it is something students must be able to understand very clearly. This is a way to help them play with this idea in a friendly manner.

If we **re-group** again, we can ask students how they’d describe the following:

I’m thinking that we might hear something like **1 group of 16 groups of 2** or similar.

And then finally, 32 cubes total:

Wow, that was a lot of manipulating for something as seemingly simple as **4 x 8**.

Something I mention to teachers when sharing out **visual number talks **like this is how many times students have not only had to wrestle with conceptual understanding, but also practice their math facts in order to come to the final answer. It’s like we’ve tricked them into practicing math facts, but built on the conceptual underpinnings!

DOUBLE-WHAMMY!

## Unpacking What’s Really Happening Here

### Number Properties “Under the Hood” of the Halving and Doubling Strategy

While it might not seem apparent initially, we have done a lot with **number properties **in order to be able to apply a **halving and doubling strategy** to this seemingly simple multiplication problem.

Let’s take a closer look.

In order to apply a **halving and doubling **or **doubling and halving **strategy, we must **decompose** the number to be **halved** into a **half **and **double**, in this case, decomposing 4 into factors of 2 and 2.

Right there lies the half and the double, or **2 groups of 2 groups of 8**. Note that the factors of **2 **and **2 **are still associated with one another (hence the brackets around them):

Since the intention here is to **half **the **4 **and **double **the **8**, we must **re-associate **a factor of **2 **with the **8**.

The result is **2 groups of 2 groups of 8 **or **2 groups of 8, copied 2 times**.

We could also **commute **the factors of **2 **and **8** in order to regroup into what would visually appear to be **2 groups of ****8 groups of ****2** or **8 groups of 2****, copied 2 times**:

When you re-group the **8 groups of 2** through simplification to **16**, we can now see **2 groups of 16**:

Here, we can clearly see the **halving** and **doubling** taking place.

While not necessary, you can explicitly see the **identity property **at play here by placing a **single group** inside another **single group**:

If you want to play around with more number properties, we can **commute** the factor of **2 **and **re-associate **it with the factor of **16 **using the **commutative **and **associative ****properties**:

And finally, by simplifying, our result would be **1 group of 32 **or simply **32 **squares total.

Thanks for watching and reading!

Did you use this in your classroom or at home? How’d it go? Post in the comments!

**Math IS Visual. Let’s teach it that way.**

Dive into conceptual math talks that are embedded in problem based math units for use with your students now!

We loved this lesson for 32 so much that we tried 17 the next day and another spectacular number talk in grade 3 /4 .

This is wonderful news to hear! So happy that you are finding the visual prompts helpful!

Should I hear someone speaking in the video? Or is it just visual and I narrate for students?

Hi Kim – No these are silent visual prompts. You get to do all the prompting / pausing / facilitating!

[…] including subitizing, abstraction, and unitizing which quickly develops into addition, subtraction, multiplication and division. Then, possibly without even knowing it, kids find themselves in a world of fractions, […]

What’s happening is you are doubling one number and halving the other because then the sum evens out. Zach S

If you double one factor and halve the other in a multiplication equation, the product will be the same as in the prior equation. This is true because each group is twice as small, but there are two times as many groups.

– Lola GG